How big is actually too big? Amazon sparks antitrust concerns

Amazon’s bid to acquire Whole Foods has sparked political concerns as well as prompted policymakers as well as legal experts to ask: How big is actually too big?, America’s fifth-largest company by market value, is actually still growing like an adolescent as well as planting flags in brand new markets. in which is actually prompting some policymakers as well as legal experts to ask: How big is actually too big?

This kind of’s a key issue for an economy being rapidly reshaped by e-commerce, a sector where Amazon as well as the merchants operating on its platform account for up to a third of all U.S. sales, according to some estimates.

This kind of’s also critical for Seattle, a city in which has hitched its wagon to the e-commerce titan, as well as in which once saw another local champion, Microsoft, mired in a lengthy antitrust battle. in which fight, over Microsoft keeping a rival internet browser off PCs running Windows, almost led to the split-up of the Redmond software giant.

E-commerce is actually not Amazon’s only game. This kind of also dominates cloud computing, as well as This kind of may soon have a significant brick-as well as-mortar presence, with its pending acquisition of Whole Foods Market. The unexpected $13.7 billion deal announced in June spurred an outcry among critics of the company as well as some members of Congress who asked the Federal Trade Commission to take a close look at the deal.

Most Read Stories

Unlimited Digital Access. $1 for 4 weeks.

Last month Marc Perrone, president of the United Food as well as Commercial Workers International Union, which represents grocery workers, wrote to the FTC in which Amazon’s proposed takeover of the organic food purveyor “is actually a competitive threat to our economy in which will hurt workers as well as communities.”

Legal experts say This kind of’s definitely hard to build an antitrust case against the Whole Foods deal, which could give Amazon just a smaller percentage of the U.S. grocery market.

Amazon’s budding dominance in some other markets, too, is actually likely to remain unchallenged inside the long term, unless the philosophy underlying antitrust regulations modifications. In fact, U.S. regulators have sided with Amazon against its rivals’ anti-competitive moves — such as when they charged Apple as well as top brand new York publishers with conspiring to raise prices for e-books, a market Amazon dominates.

Under the current U.S. antitrust view, how consumers are treated is actually the prime factor, not the company’s dominance in a market. To take antitrust action against Amazon, regulators could have to prove in which the company somehow harms shoppers — for example, by conspiring to make the products they buy artificially more expensive. Another way Amazon could run into trouble is actually by undermining rivals with strategies such as sustained predatory pricing or forcing suppliers to lock out competitors.

however rather than using tactics like in which, some experts say, Amazon has built its empire just by giving customers what they want — products at low prices with lots of choices — which is actually not against the rules, no matter how big This kind of grows.

“Antitrust law doesn’t make This kind of illegal to get market power,” provided This kind of was done properly, said A. Douglas Melamed, a professor of antitrust law at Stanford University as well as a former U.S. Department of Justice antitrust official.

Amazon’s humongous size is actually “politically important,” however not an antitrust issue. “Not if they got there by being more innovative as well as more creative than the next guy,” he said.

At the same time, the huge role occupied by Amazon — as well as some other big tech firms such as Google as well as Facebook — is actually fostering a rethinking among policy wonks about how government can oversee the power of these large tech companies.

“A lot of people are waking up to the fact in which Amazon has positioned itself as a central piece of infrastructure for the 21st century economy,” said Lina Khan, a fellow at the brand new America Foundation, a Washington, D.C., think tank. She is actually also author of “Amazon’s Antitrust Paradox,” which has attracted widespread attention since This kind of was published in January by the Yale Law Journal.

“We need to rethink how to go about preserving competition,” she said in an interview.

Amazon downplays the antitrust issue. During a recent call with reporters, Amazon Chief Financial Officer Brian Olsavsky said in which “the businesses we are in are all very large market segments with lots of very serious competition.”

Nevertheless, the company last year hired a veteran D.C. antitrust adviser, Seth Bloom.

producing rivals quake

Amazon’s North American retail sales, which include Canada, totaled about $80 billion in 2016. in which doesn’t include sales by third-party merchants operating on Amazon’s site, which some experts estimate to be about the same, or more.

Together, Amazon as well as its merchants account for about a third of all online sales. however e-commerce is actually a tiny part — about 8.15 percent — of the huge U.S. retail sector.

Amazon grows fast, however. inside the latest quarter, the company’s sales grew 25 percent, to $38 billion, as well as the company is actually on track to becoming the second-largest U.S. employer among the Fortune 500, after Wal-Mart.

This kind of dominates some markets, such as e-books. In others, This kind of’s growing so quickly in which This kind of makes incumbents quake. For instance, analysts with Cowen estimate in which Amazon might surpass Macy’s as the biggest seller of clothes This kind of year.

When a rumor arises in which Amazon might dip its toe in a brand new market, stocks for potential rivals tremble, as happened to Zillow in June amid reports of a potential Amazon service for real-estate agents.

Even more important than its retail power, inside the eyes of some policymakers, is actually Amazon’s increasingly central role as a platform widely used by some other retailers. Brands right now feel compelled to hawk their wares on Amazon’s site, the biggest destination for online shoppers.

Many merchants also pay to use Amazon’s logistics, having their products stored as well as shipped by the Seattle giant. Amazon, the largest purveyor of cloud computing, even rents competitors the computing capacity they need to operate their businesses.

Khan, the brand new America fellow, likens Amazon to the 19th century railroad empires in which farmers as well as manufacturers relied on to get their products to market — as well as whose power generated public concern in which led to the creation of the first federal antitrust laws.

“Today you have to ride Amazon’s rails,” she said.

Current antitrust laws, which focus on protecting efficiency as well as consumer prices, are ill-suited to regulate in which type of power. They also don’t fully take into account how Amazon’s bevy of mutually reinforcing businesses can undermine competition, Khan argues.

however in which regulatory framework could change. inside the past year, the attention the issue has been getting coming from the media as well as members of Congress on both sides of the aisle “has been mind-blowing,” Khan said.

In a recent Op-Ed inside the brand new York Times, Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., pointed to more strict oversight of corporate giants among the main points of the Democratic Party program.

“We are going to fight to allow regulators to break up big companies if they’re hurting consumers as well as to make This kind of harder for companies to merge if This kind of reduces competition,” he wrote.

Clear runway in U.S.

Experts say the Whole Foods deal is actually likely to sail through, despite the initial controversy.

Melamed, the Stanford professor, said in which the grocery chain as well as Amazon today barely compete. Whole Foods, with annual sales of about $16 billion, represents a tiny sliver of the $0 billion U.S. grocery market. as well as Amazon’s U.S. grocery as well as pantry sales totaled just $400 million inside the first quarter of 2017, according to calculations by One Click Retail, an e-commerce consultancy.

inside the longer term, too, Melamed sees a relatively clear runway for Amazon, as long as This kind of behaves.

He acknowledged there is actually some restlessness among experts regarding the relative passivity of antitrust regulators in recent decades.

“There’s an increasing sentiment, even among the antitrust technocrats, in which perhaps antitrust law has not been aggressive enough,” he said. in which laxity has allowed, inside the eyes of critics, a series of gigantic deals across the U.S. economy in which have increased market concentration.

however Melamed expects any regulatory modifications in which may occur to be relatively minor — perhaps closer scrutiny of upcoming deals, or looking at a longer-term horizon when projecting whether a merger might result in competitive harm.

A bigger challenge to Amazon might come coming from Europe.

Last June, the European Commission fined Google some $2.7 billion for allegedly giving its own cost-comparison service an illegal advantage by featuring This kind of prominently in search results.

Melamed said European regulators don’t like the creation of monopolies, even if they result coming from disruptive practices in which could be considered acceptable inside the U.S. “If you wind up driving your only competitor out of business, This kind of’s going to land you in trouble in Europe.”

This kind of’s hard to know how This kind of could impact Amazon. however the company has already had run-ins with European antitrust regulators. In 2015 the European Commission began investigating Amazon’s e-book distribution agreements with publishers, which required the publishers to share with Amazon information about the terms they struck with Amazon’s competitors, as well as to give This kind of the same or better terms.

Amazon agreed not to enforce those clauses as well as to drop them coming from future contracts, a commitment the Commission made legally binding in May.

Back inside the U.S., even though building a case against Amazon might be hard, This kind of doesn’t mean rivals or critics won’t try.

The disruptive effect of Amazon’s expansion on competitors could force some politically connected firms to ask regulators for help, said David Teece, director of the Tusher Center for the Management of Intellectual Capital at the Haas School of Business at UC Berkeley. “The greater the disruption, the more likelihood the antitrust agencies are going to stick their nose in This kind of,” he said.

Communication will be key for the titan.

“Amazon’s not there yet. however when This kind of gets to be dominant, This kind of has to be careful, make sure all its conduct is actually pro-competitive as well as the public understands This kind of,” he added.

“You can’t ignore Washington, D.C. Bill Gates learned in which.”

,, 7 August 2017 | 3:13 pm

Source : How big is actually too big? Amazon sparks antitrust concerns