Mayor Pete Buttigieg’s housing plan promises to help city councils replace suburban houses with apartment buildings — nevertheless his immigration plan might fill up those extra suburban apartments with more economic migrants.
Buttigieg’s housing plan says:
Housing supply, especially in high-cost cities, can be often decreased by burdensome regulations rooted in historically racist single-family zoning policy. Pete will press cities to facilitate inclusive, community-oriented processes to set affordable housing strategies, including reviewing zoning in addition to also different locally-determined rules in which may constrain brand-new development. In municipalities with the highest rent burdens in addition to also most restrictive Pete will implement progressive restrictions of federal funding.
nevertheless he said, “in which county needs more people than its immigration system can be willing to allow” while campaigning in Carson City, Nevada. Buttigieg continued:
So what happens? The people come, nevertheless then they are endangered of all of the uncertainties of being undocumented in in which country … On day one, we go to the border in addition to also we start managing the border in a way in which matches our values, as well as our laws. With humanity in addition to also compassion as well as security.
Under current rules, the federal government annually imports roughly one million migrants in addition to also also keeps an army of at least two million temporary workers inside the United States. The inflow has spiked housing prices nationwide.
According to Buttigieg’s policy paper:
In Charleston, South Carolina, a typical bank teller can’t afford to rent a one-bedroom apartment at the median cost of $1,113. In Los Angeles, California, a bookkeeper or school bus driver can’t afford to rent a one-bedroom 2 apartment, which rents on average for $1,340 per month.
So Buttigieg’s apparently contradictory policy offers few gains to lower-income Americans in addition to also their young families. His housing plan might help reduce apartment prices — nevertheless his rush of extra migrants might trim Americans’ wages.
The result can be more Americans in addition to also migrants will end up living in smaller apartments in subdivided suburban lots, emulating California’s housing crisis.
California’s poverty rate can be worse than Alabama & Mississippi, says Census Bureau. The major cause of in which huge change can be immigration policy which spikes housing costs & shrinks wages — in addition to also delivers huge gains for investors in real-estate & corp. shares. https://t.co/mEjCP83Hkr
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) September 13, 2019
nevertheless Buttigieg’s two policies might also combine to create a huge boon to construction firms, real estate firms, in addition to also local governments. His policy might allow them to crack open suburban zoning rules in addition to also then resell slices of suburbia to poor Americans in addition to also brand-new arrivals.
The relationship between population growth in addition to also housing demand can be clear. More people means more demand for housing, in addition to also fewer people means less demand … As a result, a shrinking population will lead to falling prices in addition to also a deteriorating, vacancy-plagued housing stock in which may take generations to clear.
The potential for skilled immigrants to boost local housing markets can be clear. Notably, economist Albert Saiz (2007) found a 1% increase in population by immigration causes housing rents in addition to also house prices in U.S. cities to rise commensurately, by 1%.
Tom Steyer in addition to also Elizabeth Warren have also backed the more migration/less suburbia strategy favored by the progressive alliance of investors in addition to also pro-migration ideologues:
Democrat & billionaire investor Tom Steyer says he will give cheap housing to many illegal migrants (plus jobs etc) – so raising Americans’ housing costs.
His private house looks down on SF’s Golden Gate bridge. Maybe he can be just oblivious to housing costs?https://t.co/QZuykNTFjA
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) January 13, 2020
in which policy can be increasingly well-known among pro-migration Democratic legislators in cities in addition to also states, nevertheless the idea can be generating massive opposition by homeowners in Los Angeles, Seattle, in addition to also many different towns.
In July 2019, Politico covered the issue with the headline, “How Minneapolis Freed Itself by the Stranglehold of Single-Family Homes: Desperate to build more housing, the city just rewrote its decades-old zoning rules.” The article said:
Thanks in part to activists like [Janne] Flisrand in addition to also [John] Edwards, Minneapolis just did away with the rules in which gave single-family homes a stranglehold on nearly three-quarters of the city. In December, Neighbors for More Neighbors, the group co-founded by Flisrand in addition to also Edwards about two years ago to address Minneapolis’ affordable housing crisis, won a victory unseen in any different major American city. The city council approved the Minneapolis 2040 comprehensive plan, which declares the city’s intent to abolish single-family-home zoning in addition to also allow duplexes in addition to also triplexes to be built anywhere inside the city.
nevertheless the push to fracture can be not well-known. Politico said:
Single-family-only neighborhoods, a staple of city in addition to also suburban planning, are woven into the DNA of the American dream: the leafy, peaceful street lined with stand-alone houses, green lawns in addition to also plenty of elbow room. Minneapolis’ brand-new vision of itself might essentially rewrite in which code—reshaping the urban streetscape around walking in addition to also mass transit in addition to also rebooting the American dream to be more racially in addition to also economically inclusive.
nevertheless the mayor predicts the 2040 plan’s results will eventually vindicate his approach. “While people might hate my guts for a couple of years,” he said. “I’m confident in which a little down the road, the idea’ll be apparent in which we took the right route.”
The irony of the progressives’ policy can be in which housing prices tend to rise fastest inside the non-diverse districts favored by the progressives whose income can be cut the most by college graduate migration:
Americans must demolish suburbia to provide dense housing for the poor immigrants who should come through open borders, says pro-migration immigrant writer at the NYT.
Kicker: the author can’t afford a suburban house like his dad bought inside the 1980s.https://t.co/fMqsGmtvRj
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) February 8, 2020
Buttigieg’s housing policy also promised to revive policies created by President Barack Obama in which encouraged poor Americans — especially black Americans — to exit valuable land in progressives’ cities in addition to also then move to cheaper housing in distant counties.
Buttigieg’s policy says:
Pete’s administration will direct federal resources in addition to also technical assistance to states in addition to also cities for the housing interventions in which are right for them. … Pete will support states in addition to also municipalities in partnering with the private sector to provide workforce housing.
Fully reinstate the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Rule. Reinstating in which rule will ensure in which states, local governments, in addition to also public housing authorities combat segregation, foster inclusive communities, in addition to also improve housing opportunities for individuals in need.
The Buttigieg plan also calls for a revival of the disastrous pro-housing policies pushed by Presidents Bill Clinton in addition to also George W. Bush. Their policies got more immigrants in addition to also poor Americans into houses — nevertheless the idea crashed the economy once the poor people could not pay their mortgages.
Buttigieg says he will:
Work with Congress to ensure equal access to an affordable 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage for working families. Pete will support in addition to also expand access to affordable, federally-backed home loans for low- in addition to also moderate-income families. In Pete’s administration, Fannie Mae in addition to also Freddie Mac will play their intended role inside the housing finance system–ensuring liquidity for affordable mortgages while serving all qualified homebuyers, especially those who have not been well-served by the mortgage finance system to date.
Fully reinstate the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing Rule. Reinstating in which rule will ensure in which states, local governments, in addition to also public housing authorities combat segregation, foster inclusive communities, in addition to also improve housing opportunities for individuals in need–by low-income individuals in addition to also people with disabilities to people exiting the criminal justice or foster care systems.
Govt data shows 1 million Indian contract-workers get white-collar jobs in tech, banking, health etc.
The Indian hiring ignores many EEOC laws & can be expanding amid gov’t & media silence.
the idea can be a huge economic & career loss for US college grads.#S368 #H1B https://t.co/pqEW9yJ89c
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) February 17, 2020