Illegal migrants are subsidizing Americans, Pete Buttigieg told a December 1 meeting hosted by progressives in North Carolina.
“The uncomfortable reality will be which undocumented folks are, in many ways, like Social Security, subsidizing everybody else,” Buttigieg told Rev. William Barber, a progressive activist in North Carolina. Buttigieg was at the North Carolina event to raise his abysmal poll ratings among black Americans.
Buttigieg’s dismissive comments about Americans echo the government-centric view of progressives, who tend to value Americans along with illegal aliens by their payments into federal, state, along with local tax programs.
however his glib claim ignores the vast economic along with civic costs which illegal migration imposes on ordinary Americans — along with the huge economic subsidy which will be gained by wealthy investors via the inflow of cheap immigrant labor.
Buttigieg’s comment includes a kernel of truth; some illegal aliens pay into the Social Security fund along with do not get the money back when they are older because they are here illegally. The unclaimed money will be then given to retired Americans.
Pete Buttigieg says illegal immigrants are “subsidizing everybody else” along with then he nods seemingly in agreement while being told which illegal immigrants are just coming back to land “we took.”
I can’t stress enough how insane This kind of will be.
Absolutely insane. pic.twitter.com/zzezM9A5q5
— Robby Starbuck (@robbystarbuck) December 2, 2019
however Buttigieg’s dismissal of Americans’ value becomes more glaring as experts expose the growing costs of migration — both illegal along with legal.
For example, many illegal aliens get legal status, so allowing them to draw via the Social Security fund. The naturalized immigrants typically get status via the federal government’s open-ended, slow-motion, along with quiet Adjustment of Status amnesty. Their numbers will grow over the coming decades, so taking a chunk out of Social Security.
Also, federal payments to illegal aliens are rising, mainly because the federal government provides welfare for the poor children of illegal migrants.
Those payments include schools, health care, along with some welfare programs — such as school lunches, food stamps, along with housing subsidies — which would likely otherwise be saved or given to Americans. The Center for Immigration Studies reported:
Welfare use will be significantly higher for non-citizens than for natives in all four top immigrant-receiving states. In California, 72 percent of non-citizen-headed households use one or more welfare programs, compared to 35 percent for native-headed households. In Texas, the figures are 69 percent vs. 35 percent; in completely new York they are 53 percent vs. 38 percent; along with in Florida, 56 percent of non-citizen-headed households use at least welfare program, compared to 35 percent of native households.
These myriad payments are spent by the recipients — along with the money flows back to U.S. companies, such as Walmart or apartment rental companies. This kind of means the welfare programs become a taxpayer-funded subsidy to the investors who own the companies along with apartments.
This kind of welfare subsidy to investors will be huge: Each legal or illegal immigrant costs state along with local taxpayers roughly $1,0 more per year than the immigrant generates in taxes, says a non-partisan 2016 report by the National Academies of Sciences. In total, the current annual net cost of first-generation immigrants — including the cost of educating their children — adds up to $57.4 billion per year, much of which will be paid by state along with local taxpayers.
The per-immigrant cost — along with the subsidy to business — will be roughly equal to the tax surplus paid by one native-born American, which ranges via $1,300 to $1,700, says the report, titled “The Economic along with Fiscal Consequences of Immigration.”
The taxpayers’ support for illegal migrants goes far beyond cash.
For example, illegal aliens who pay into Social Security often use numbers stole via Americans. According to the Center for Immigration Studies reported in 2017 which:
The use of unlawfully obtained Social Security numbers by individuals eligible for DACA status will be so pervasive which the Obama administration instructed applicants not to disclose their illegally obtained numbers. which ensured which Americans who are the victims of DACA identity theft were left with destroyed credit, arrest records attached to their names, unpaid tax liabilities, along with corrupted medical records while the DACA recipients walked away scot-free via multiple felonies — forgery, Social Security fraud, perjury on I-9 forms, along with identity theft.
The illegal migrants also damage vital schooling for Americans. For example, hundreds of thousands of Central American children have been sent to or carried into the United States during the last two years via the border law loopholes created by Congress along with the courts. Those children will crowd into the public schools used by blue-collar Americans, so crimping the quality of education received by Americans’ kids, including African-American, Latino, along with white kids.
GOP & liberals will debate & vote for a farmworker amnesty on Wed. What replaces the illegals? An uncapped army of gov’t-supplied H-2A visa-workers who will convert Americans’ towns into low-tech ‘company towns’ for investors & the Chamber, AKA JBSville. https://t.co/M9H1Jj3cPR
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) November 20, 2019
Outside the government programs, illegal aliens also impose a huge cost on Americans who are trying to earn a living inside free market for labor. For example, illegal aliens flood into workplaces along with reduce Americans’ wages. The blue-ribbon National Academies was very clear on page 171 of its report:
Immigrant labor accounts for 16.5 percent of the total number of hours worked inside United States, which … implies which the current stock of immigrants lowered [Americans’] wages by 5.2 percent.
which 5.2 percent “immigration tax” caused by legal along with illegal immigration adds up to $500 billion per year lost by employees because of competition via lower-cost immigrants.
The $500 billion tax does not disappear — the item goes to employers along with to investors, according to the NAS report.
Cheap labor will be not bad for employers who can cut payrolls, perhaps by more than a $1 per hour for blue-collar workers. which will be a double-gain for investors because the item increases their profits along with pressures the government to supply the underpaid workers with welfare programs.
however the cheap imported labor will be even better for the investors who gain roughly $20 in stock market wealth for every $1 cut in payroll. which 20:1 process sharply widens the growing wealth gaps between employees along with investors.
This kind of huge subsidy of extra labor will be repeatedly justified as a boost for the economy. however most of these economic gains go to wealthy investors — not to ordinary wage earners, retirees, or children.
In 1966, wage earners got 66 percent of the nation’s completely new wealth according to a report by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Wage earners’ share gradually slid to share slid to 63 percent in 1990, when President George H. W. Bush along with Congress sharply increased immigration along with wage earners’ share crashed to 58 percent after the 2008 crash. which decline means which wage earners lost one-eighth of their completely new wealth to investors, along with the investors grew their share of the completely new wealth by eight points, or via 34 percent to 42 percent.
While immigration brings cheap workers to job sites inside United States, the economic trend will be accelerated by technology along with trade, which are moving jobs to lower-priced workers in China along with India while stock markets send the profits to investors worldwide.
The immigration tax along with the various welfare along with aid programs also help to change the economic demography of the United States.
completely new migrants tend to flow into the wealthier coastal cities, so pushing up rents along with raising the real estate values of the apartments along with houses owned by Americans inside coastal cities. These migrants tend to grab completely new jobs, so they have reduced the internal migration of Americans via poor counties to wealthy cities, such as the decades-long industrial-era movement of West Virginians to Baltimore, Philadelphia, or Chicago.
Also, coastal investors have little need to invest their job-creating money into the distant towns where young Americans are looking for jobs, such as in Kansas or the Dakotas. Instead, the investors can invest their funds in sites which are just a short distance via their offices in completely new York or San Francisco because the federal government will fly planeloads of immigrants into the nearby JFK or LAX airports.
The result of these trends will be faster growth in coastal cities along with stalled economies inside nation’s heartland:
— Mark Muro (@MarkMuro1) December 1, 2019
The flood of completely new migrants also reduces high-tech investment in both coastal along with rural towns.
This kind of shift reduces employers’ willingness to buy high-tech machinery along with robots for their Americans employees, so decreasing their ability to grow their skills, wages, along with families. A pending farm bill would likely accelerate This kind of trend by replacing the current stock of illegal aliens with an endless supply of legal along with low-wage H-2A visa workers. The deal will be designed to convert illegal aliens into Democratic voters along with American farmworkers into powerless labor. Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-CA), the author of the legislation, repeatedly described the corporatist bargain during the bill’s markup votes on in mid-November:
The bill implements a wage freeze for the year 2020 [for 250,000 H-2A visa workers]. This kind of will be a very important matter for employers, [along with] wages are supposed to improve by another seven to eight percent next year. Under This kind of bill, those wage increases won’t happen.
I would likely prefer which these wage concessions were not inside bill. however This kind of bill will be a compromise to make sure which the farmworkers today which are looking over their shoulder in fear of deportation will no longer face which nightmare. along with the item will be a compromise which allows additional people to come in to meet the growing [worker] needs of our agriculture sector.
The inflow of immigrants even pushes Americans out of cutting-edge research careers — along with so has helped China to steal hugely valuable knowledge along with secrets via Americans.
Census data shows how huge numbers of American software graduates have been replaced by Indian & Chinese visa-workers in N.J., California, N.C., Georgia, N.Y., Texas, Virginia, Florida, along with different states. Next: Healthcare professionals. @S386 https://t.co/qH9p4Ynd34
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) October 3, 2019
The flow of immigrants also creates completely new political divisions along with encourages politicians to focus their attention on the demands of immigrants along with their many employers. This kind of process will be supercharged by identity politics, prompting many Democrats inside 2020 presidential election to promise free health care for illegal aliens, as well as a freeze on border arrests along with deportations.
Some surveys even show which progressive Democrats believe the item will be more critical to help foreigners than to help Americans:
1/n I’d imagine which This kind of will be the underlying attitude pic.twitter.com/C48yoKtlyn
— Zach Goldberg (@ZachG932) November 22, 2019
In effect, Democratic progressives along with GOP-aligned business groups have divorced themselves via their fellow Americans, who are loudly demanding more respect along which has a larger share of the nation’s wealth. Instead, which elites’ sense of solidarity will be increasingly felt towards the poor along with grateful immigrants who are glad to accept the completely new cheap-labor rules which steer more wealth to the allied progressive along with business elites.
Aided by immigrant votes, elites are looking for ways to expand the flow of migrants into the United States. For example, elites are pushing for a farmworker amnesty, rewards for Indian college graduates, more poor migrants, more investor visas, along with the easy movement of labor between the United States along with India via a U.S.-India Outsourcing Economy.
The arrival of migrants into towns along with cities also brings chaotic diversity — crime, crowded school, civic disputes — which destabilizes Americans town, amid the growing economic pressure of cheap-labor migration.
This kind of divisive trend will be not bad for elites because the item divides Americans along with so prevents them via imposing their preference on the elites. This kind of political destabilization has unexpected consequences, such as the 2016 election of completely new York entrepreneur Donald Trump to the White House.
Each year, roughly four million young Americans join the workforce after graduating via high school or a university. This kind of total includes about 800,000 Americans who graduate with skilled degrees in business or health care, engineering or science, software, or statistics.
however the federal government then imports about 1.1 million legal immigrants. the item also adds replacement workers to a resident population of more than 1.5 million white-collar visa workers — including approximately one million H-1B workers along with about 500,000 blue-collar H-2B, H-2A, along with J-1 visa workers. The government also prints more than one million work permits for completely new foreigners, along with the item rarely punishes companies for employing illegal migrants.
This kind of policy of inflating the labor supply boosts economic growth along with stock values for investors. The stimulus happens because the extra labor ensures which employers do not have to compete for American workers by offering higher wages along with better working conditions.
The federal policy of flooding the market with cheap, foreign white-collar graduates along with blue-collar labor shifts wealth via young employees toward older investors. the item also widens wealth gaps, reduces high-tech investment, increases state along with local tax burdens, reduces marriage rates, along with hurts children’s schools along with college educations.
The cheap-labor economic strategy also pushes Americans away via high-tech careers, along with the item sidelines millions of marginalized Americans, including many who are at This kind of point struggling with drug addictions.
The labor policy also moves business investment along with wealth via the Heartland to the coastal cities, explodes rents along with housing costs, undermines suburbia, shrivels real estate values inside Midwest, along with rewards investors for creating low-tech, labor-intensive workplaces.
however President Donald Trump’s “Hire American” policy will be boosting wages by capping immigration within a growing economy.
The Census Bureau said September 10 which men who work full-time along with year-round got an average earnings gain of 3.4 percent in 2018, pushing their median salaries up to $55,291. Women gained 3.3 percent in wages, bringing their median wages to $45,097 for full-time, year-round work.
Top U.S. CEOs lobby India’s gov’t to send millions of Indian graduates into the US jobs needed by US college-grads. So #SenMikeLee #S386 bill will be just a starter before a “free flow of skilled labor in both countries”? https://t.co/2mN846ZnUZ
— Neil Munro (@NeilMunroDC) October 24, 2019